follow us on twitter

dOc on facebook

Microsoft Store

Share: email   Print      Technorati.gif   StumbleUpon.gif   MySpace   digg.gif delicious.gif   google.gif   magnolia.gif   facebook.gif
Permalink: Permalink.gif

Buy from Amazon

Buy from Amazon.com

Quickband presents
Short 10: Chaos (2000)

Guy 1: "Knock Knock: Knock, Knock."
Guy 2: "Who's There: Who's there?"
Guy 1: "Knock Knock: Don't you understand that communication is impossible?"

- from Po Mo Knock Knock

Review By: Dan Lopez   
Published: October 25, 2000

Stars: various
Other Stars: Various
Director: George Lucas and others

Manufacturer: Warner Advanced Media Operations
MPAA Rating: Not Rated for (some language, mild violence)
Run Time: approx. 01h:36m:15s
Release Date: November 07, 2000
UPC: 085393724726
Genre: compilation

Image Transfer
Audio Transfer
B- BB+C+ B

DVD Review

Volume 10 of the short film DVD magazine, Short, is entitled 'Chaos.' Perhaps not totally appropriate, the theme certainly has some effect on a few of the shorts, and once againsome amateur and possibly 'unknown' filmmakers get some good exposure

Section 1: Chaos

The first section of the disc features 3 very short films, all of which are called Chaos. One is aquick video segment of skateboarders having horrible painful accidents while trying to performimpressive tricks. The second Chaos short is a brief animated piece. Last is a film about"animals going bad," and it certainly provides a good laugh or two.

Section 2: Classic

Electronic Labyrinth: THX-1138 4EB
Directed by George Lucas

Lucas' legendary short film (one of a handful he made while at USC) is presented here in it'sentirety. Electronic Labyrinth, for those of you unfamiliar with it, was the source forLucas' first major film, THX-1138, and is arguably one of his best works considering theexperimental and surreal nature. The film tells the story of a man (THX-1138) attempting toescape from an overly controlling and oppressive mechanical society. The feature film heavilyexpanded the concept and used bigger actors and effects. Along with the film is included a shortinterview clip with one of George Lucas' instructors at USC and a brief explanation of what theTHX/Lucasfilm audio standard means.

Section 3: Narrative

Five Feet High and Rising
Directed by Peter Sollett.

The longest feature on the disc is this 30-minute piece that follows the life of a young boy in anurban city neighborhood. Using amateur casting and real neighborhood kids, the film succeeds asa very realistic portrayal of this child's day. The film is accompanied by a commentary track withdirector Peter Sollett.

The Fly
Directed by Ferenc Rófusz.

This is a very short animated piece of life as seen through the eyes of a fly. It won an Academy Award® in 1980 and has long been a fan favorite of short film festivals.

Directed by Tahsin Ozgur.

This animated piece is a very humorous, short portrayal of a Turkish eatery owner. The actualfilm is accompanied by a recipe for Doner Kabob (better known as 'Gyros') as well as some otherfunny tidbits about the short.

Section 4: Student

Still Revolutionaries
Directed by Sienna McLean.

Running about 15 minutes, this feature is a very well made, small documentary about two womenwho were once part of the Black Panther movement. The documentary marks an interesting turnin the media-based history of the Black Panthers in that it focuses on their social programs andcommunity outreach programs more than the typical, violent image they gained. An informativecommentary by the director is included.

Directed by Andrew Busti & Sebastian Castillo.

This piece is a short, experimental film done entirely with frames created using a xerox machine,with only a musical soundtrack as accompaniment. I didn't like it very much, but it's still aninteresting technique. A commentary with the directors is included, though short.

The Bottomless Cup
Directed by Paul Bonner.

Probably the best offering on the disc (other than Electronic Labyrinth) is this film abouta weird encounter that a driver has at a late-night diner. Includes a commentary track and aninterview with the actress who plays the waitress in the short.

Section 5: Experimental

Po Mo Knock Knock
Directed by Greg Pak.

This short is a satire of "artsy" type movies, featuring two guys telling 'knock-knock' jokes to eachother in black-and-white, using a very Ingmar Bergman style approach. It's pretty funny and thefact that it's only about 3 minutes long means the joke isn't stretched thin. A serious commentary trackis included, as is an alternate "special edition" commentary where the cast and director arewatching The Matrix instead of their own film. A second short film, Po Mo LoveDoc is also included that follows up on the relationship between characters from the short.

Section 6: Music

Directed by Gav Barbey.

This unusual film is a sort of meandering pseudo-documentary about a truck driver, set to verybluesy music. It has won several awards and was featured as part of the Sundance Film Festival,but I have to admit I didn't really like it much. Regardless, it's well made and an additionalcommentary track with the director is featured.

The rest of the disc is just little humorous snippets and weird stuff (including the disc credits),with nothing really significant beyond the short films. While all these films make a good viewing,the disc seemed a little thin on material, especially since most of the films are so short.

Rating for Style: B-
Rating for Substance: B


Image Transfer

Aspect Ratio1.33:1 - Full Frame
Original Aspect Ratioyes

Image Transfer Review: Most of the shorts are 1:33:1, with only one (Burnout) presented in 1:75:1. The imagequality is excellent, with no signs of compression artifacts or pixelization problems. Even aheavily aged film like Electronic Labyrinth comes across with vivid detail. Most of thefilms use very low-tech methods, so the source prints are not High-Def quality or anything, but thetransfer here is without substantial flaws, probably maxing out the space on the disc.

Image Transfer Grade: B+


Audio Transfer

 LanguageRemote Access
Dolby Digital

Audio Transfer Review: Much like my experience with Quickband's Circuit music DVDs, the disc uses Dolby 5.1sound for everything on the disc. These mixes are not specifically engineered for the films,however, but rather awkward ones where the mono sound data is pumped into each channel. Theresult is a very harsh sound mix that's very distracting. It's not real surround sound, it's just loud. Thankfully, this doesn't really hurt any of the films, but it does exaggerate source flaws like hissand tape hum. The only portion of the disc with 'real' 5.1 sound (true directionality) are themenus.

Audio Transfer Grade: C+


Disc Extras

Animated menu with music
Scene Access with 0 cues and remote access
1 Other Trailer(s) featuring The Perfect Storm
Packaging: Snapper
Picture Disc
1 Disc
1-Sided disc(s)
Layers: dual

Extras Review: The production notes and commentary material for the short films make a nice bonus for each separate film. Other than that, the disc doesn't really have much else, but then it doesn't reallyneed much else. There is a trailer for The Perfect Storm, as well as a teaser for the nextvolume of Short.

Extras Grade: B


Final Comments

Short 10 is another good dose of unusual and amateur filmmaking. I'm not sure, though,whether or not this would warrant a purchase or a rental. I'd have to lean towards rental. Thedisc does, however, make the incorrect assumption that because it has ElectronicLabyrinth this is the first DVD of a George Lucas film. Actually, Lucas' AmericanGrafitti has been on the medium for over 2 years. Oops! Regardless, I recommend the disc.


Back to top

Microsoft Store

On Facebook!
Promote Your Page Too



Original Magic Dress.com

Susti Heaven

Become a Reviewer | Search | Review Vault | Reviewers
Readers | Webmasters | Privacy | Contact
Microsoft Store