04/23/2014  
One Direction: Reaching for the Stars Part 2 - The Next Chapter on DVD/VOD May 13Shelter Island on DVD May 13Pennsylvania Ballet at 50 on DVD May 13Flying Tigers & Home of the Brave on Blu-ray & DVD May 13Stalingrad on Two-Disc Blu-ray with 3D, DVD & Digital May 13The Dave Clark Five And Beyond: Glad All Over on DVD & Blu-ray May 13Longmire: Season 2 on DVD May 13

follow us on twitter

dOc on facebook

NE News Editor

Stephen Colbert visits David Letterman and new 'Late Sh...
Oscar winner Lupita Nyong'o named People's most beautif...
One Direction: Reaching for the Stars Part 2 - The Next...
Shelter Island on DVD May 13...
Box Office Charts From Yahoo! Movies Apr 18- 20...

JB Joseph Burke

The Answer to American Idol's Problems Is......
CONCRETE BLONDES...
CREAM FAREWELL CONCERT...
JACK REACHER...
MANBORG...

CA Chuck Aliaga

CORRUPTION (BLU-RAY)...
THE ATTACK (BLU-RAY)...
TANK GIRL (BLU-RAY)...
HORROR STORIES...
THE UNINVITED (BLU-RAY)...

RR Rich Rosell

THE GIRL...
THE HORDE...
LIFE IS SWEET (BLU-RAY)...
SHOUT AT THE DEVIL (BLU-RAY/DVD COMBO)...
THE BLUE ANGEL (BLU-RAY)...

MZ Mark Zimmer

BABY PEGGY: THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM...
STORAGE WARS: VOLUME THREE...
Take Part in a Film Restoration...
THE 39 STEPS (BLU-RAY)...
DARK SHADOWS: THE BEST OF BARNABAS...

JS Jesse Shanks

2 BROKE GIRLS...
DOWNTON ABBEY SEASONS ONE & TWO LIMITED EDITION...
FLORENCE AND THE SPIRIT OF THE RENAISSANCE...
NAZI COLLABORATORS...
KATT WILLIAMS: KATTPACALYPSE...

RJ Ross Johnson

THE LIFE AND DEATH OF COLONEL BLIMP (BLU-RAY)...
PURPLE NOON (BLU-RAY)...
WEEKEND (BLU-RAY)...
JUAN OF THE DEAD...
THE DEVIL'S NEEDLE AND OTHER TALES OF VICE AND REDEMPTI...

JD Jon Danziger

SUNSET BOULEVARD...
SALO, OR THE 120 DAYS OF SODOM...
TABLOID...
CUL-DE-SAC...
3 WOMEN...

JC Joel Cunningham

YOJIMBO/SANJURO...
SUMMER HOURS (L'heure d'ÈtÈ)...
WIZARD OF OZ...
WINGS OF DESIRE...
HORTON HEARS A WHO!...

DH Dan Heaton

REVANCHE...
LAST DAYS OF DISCO...
NIGHTS AND WEEKENDS...
STARGATE SG-1: CHILDREN OF THE GODS...
STARGATE ATLANTIS: THE COMPLETE FIFTH SEASON...

MS Matt Serafini

THE STEPFATHER...
THE HILLS RUN RED...
MANAGEMENT...
NIGHT OF DEATH...
GNAW...

KC Kevin Clemons

Freddy Got Fingered...

JU Jeff Ulmer

Secure The Second Season of The Border on DVD August 25...
THE WALTONS: THE COMPLETE 9TH SEASON...
Dance Me Outside kicks onto DVD May 6, 2008...

DD Dale Dobson

Film-Fest 4: Sundance 2000 & Hawaii...

RM Robert Mandel

Saving Private Ryan...

Share: email   Print      Technorati.gif   StumbleUpon.gif   MySpace   digg.gif delicious.gif   google.gif   magnolia.gif   facebook.gif
Permalink: Permalink.gif



Buy from Amazon

Buy from Amazon.com

Warner Home Video presents
Criminal (2004)

"There's one thing I have learned. People fall through the cracks in life. Why does this happen? Because they don't know what they want. I don't have that problem."
- Richard (John C. Reilly)

Review By: Kevin Clemons   
Published: April 11, 2005

Stars: John C. Reilly, Diego Luena, Maggie Gyllenhaal
Other Stars: Peter Mullen
Director: Gregory Jacobs

Manufacturer: WAMO
MPAA Rating: R for language
Run Time: 01h:26m:12s
Release Date: April 12, 2005
UPC: 085393896829
Genre: crime


Style
Grade
Substance
Grade
Image Transfer
Grade
Audio Transfer
Grade
Extras
Grade
A BA-B D-

DVD Review

With all of the ridiculous laws that are passed every day in this country, would it be so hard to put forth a bill barring remakes in the film industry? No one reinterprets novels, only occasionally songs are redone, and yet movies are being remade at a record clip these days. The most recent to arrive on home video, and perhaps the biggest offender under the proposed "no remakes" bill, is Gregory Jacobs' Criminal, a remake of an Argentinian film from, well, 2000.

The film in question is Nine Queens, one that stands as the most pleasant surprise I have encountered in my years of writing for this website. The problem is that Nine Queens worked well because it was guarded in giving up its secrets, and by the time the final act came around, the pieces of a marvelously constructed puzzle fell into place. With Criminal, the pieces are there but there impact is lessened by more than half. Simply, if Nine Queens were a strategic chess match, Criminal would look more like Chutes and Ladders in comparison.

When it starts, we are introduced to Richard (Reilly) and Rodrigo (Luena), who themselves have just met after Richard decides to take Rodrigo under his wing and recruit him as his partner. After some routine (and sort of clever) small cons, an opportunity for the brass ring comes a long in the form of rare bank note that is said to be the most valuable piece of currency in North America. From there the story evolves to include a wild assortment of characters including Valerie (Gyllenhaal), Robert's sister, the hospitality manager of the hotel where Richard and Rodrigo's target is staying.

Somehow, aside from the near mirror image script and the complete lack of surprise as each puzzle piece falls into place, I found myself caught up in Criminal. Eventually, I began to appreciate it simply as a film that boasts interesting and well developed characters as well as enough energy and style to light up a small city. The director is Gregory Jacobs, an assistant director to Steven Soderberg on each of his films since 1998, and it is clear from the outset that Jacobs has been influenced by his boss and that may well be the best thing Criminal has going for it.

There should be praise for Jacobs and Soderberg (adapting the original script under the name Sam Lowry) for not dumbing down the story to be more accessible to American audiences. There are a few small changes that propel the plot, most notably in the Rodrigo character, but they wind up causing confusion once the film is over because they lead to thoughts about lapses in logic and second guesses and they ultimately diminish the overall impact of the picture.

The cast is uniformly terrific with Reilly pulling off his first leading man role with aplomb. He has the sort of sad sack look that Richard needs and he makes us feel for his character, which is saying a lot. The two best performances, for myself at least, come from Luena and Gyllenhaal (the future Mrs. Clemons if I am dreaming) as each injects a shot of charisma and charm into the film that is welcome.

Rating for Style: A
Rating for Substance: B

 

Image Transfer

 One
Aspect Ratio1.85:1 - Widescreen
Original Aspect Ratioyes
Anamorphicno


Image Transfer Review: The 1.85:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer has terrific sharpness and detail. Colors are well rendered with no bleeding evident and appear natural. There are a few instances of edge enhancement, but this occurs in isolated spots so it is not a large concern.

Image Transfer Grade: A-

 

Audio Transfer

 LanguageRemote Access
Dolby Digital
5.1
Englishyes


Audio Transfer Review: The Dolby Digital 5.1 mix is largely anchored in the center channel with smooth and crisp dialogue with no dropouts or distortion. The jazzy score comes off well in the surround speakers, making for a very nice experience.

Audio Transfer Grade: B

 

Disc Extras

Static menu with music
Scene Access with 26 cues and remote access
Subtitles/Captions in English, Spanish, French with remote access
1 Original Trailer(s)
Packaging: Amaray
Picture Disc
1 Disc
1-Sided disc(s)
Layers: RSDL

Extras Review: The films theatrical trailer is offered, and that, sadly, is it.

Extras Grade: D-

 

Final Comments

Overall, I am on the fence about Criminal. On the one hand, it is a very well made film boasting great direction, performances, and most of all a sense of energy that is intoxicating. But save yourself the time and rent the original film, Nine Queens. It is really just apples and oranges.

 


Back to top

Search 10,000+ titles:

or Advanced Search

DVD REVIEW ARCHIVE


Get FREE Shipping on all orders at TimeLife.com! - 120x90

 





Covered California

Keywords

television, late show, david letterman, stephen colbert, cbs, comedy central, the colbert report, celebrity, lupita nyong'o, people mangazine, academy award, 12 years a slave, steve mcqueen, biography, documentary, box office, movies, good morning america, abc, lara spencer, josh elliot, nbc sports, george stephanopolous, robin roberts, movie, heaven is for real, connor corum, greg kinnear, thomas haden, books, gabriel garcia marquez, nobel laureate, one hundred years of solitude, war, cannes film festival, grace of monaco, nicole kidman, kristen stewart, robert pattinson, maps to the stars, julianne moore, foxcatcher, the homesman, tommy lee jones, hilary swank, mrs. doubtfire, robin williams, fox 2000, chris columbus, david berenhaum, drama, brad pitt, general stanley mcchrystal, the operators, afghanistan war film, david michod, gone girl gillian flynn, ben affleck, rosamund pike, elvis costello, she, nine inch nails, trent reznor, atticus ross, gone girl's score, ultimate warrior, james hellwig, wrestler, heart disease, world wrestling entertainment hall of fame, animation, hbo, game of thrones, jack gleeson, king joffrey baratheon, the purple wedding, horror, fantasy, sci-fi, shailene wookley, veronica roth, allegiant, divergent, insurgent, the croods, nicolas cage, joe, david gordon green, tye sheridan, late night

On Kindle!
On Facbook!
digitallyOBSESSED!
digitallyOBSESSED!
Promote Your Page Too
Become a Reviewer | Search | Review Vault | Reviewers
Readers | Webmasters | Privacy | Contact