![]() the review site with a difference since 1999 |
||||||
| 02/09/2010 | ||||||
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
|
THE NORMA TALMADGE COLLECTION... GEORGE BERNARD SHAW ON FILM (ECLIPSE SERIES 20)... THE CONSTANCE TALMADGE COLLECTION... THE PATTY DUKE SHOW: SEASON ONE... Marie Antoinette... ABC's `Modern Family' a freshman hit... The Best and Worst Super Bowl Ads... Apollo 13 (15th Anniversary Edition) on Blu-ray Apr 13... Box Office Charts From Box Office Mojo Feb 5-7... 'Avatar' dethroned at box office by 'Dear John'... PANDORUM... LOST CITY RAIDERS... GONE WITH THE WIND... PARIS, TEXAS (BLU-RAY)... THE BROTHERS BLOOM... CHE... LOUIS ARMSTRONG: GOOD EVENING, EV'RYBODY... ROBERTO ROSSELLINI'S WAR TRILOGY... THE GOLDEN AGE OF TELEVISION... GOMORRAH... ACROSS THE HALL... GIGI (BLU-RAY)... THE HUMAN CONDITION... PLASTIC MAN: THE COMPLETE COLLECTION... INTO THE STORM... THE GENERAL (BLU-RAY)... THE EXILES... GAUMONT TREASURES 1897-1913... ELVIS: THE ED SULLIVAN SHOW... DON'T BE AFRAID OF THE DARK... WIZARD OF OZ... WINGS OF DESIRE... HORTON HEARS A WHO!... A CHARLIE BROWN CHRISTMAS... MONSOON WEDDING... IMDb Turned 19 This Past Weekend... Rotten Tomatoes Lists The Worst of the Worst Movies of ... digitallyOBSESSED.com on iPhone... 30 ROCK SEASON 3... CRASH: THE COMPLETE FIRST SEASON... THE STEPFATHER... THE HILLS RUN RED... MANAGEMENT... NIGHT OF DEATH... GNAW... Freddy Got Fingered... The Business of Strangers... Ken Burns' America: The Congress... Aqua Teen Hunger Force: Volume Two... Touki Bouki... LAST DAYS OF DISCO... NIGHTS AND WEEKENDS... STARGATE SG-1: CHILDREN OF THE GODS... STARGATE ATLANTIS: THE COMPLETE FIFTH SEASON... Star Trek: The Motion Picture... Is the Greatest American Band: Grand Funk Railroad?... Apple Updates Remote App for iPhone... I want my Internet TV!... Pundit Opinions Duel Over Meaning of Growth on TV and V... Twitter, Brillstein develop TV series... Six Points About Inglourious Basterds (spoilers)... Secure The Second Season of The Border on DVD August 25... NFB's Behind the Camera: The ABCs of Documentary Cinema... THE SWISS FAMILY ROBINSON (1976)... NFB Blog: Documentary filmmaking from the inside out... Inside the Vault Part 2: How the NFB restores and digi... Conquest of the Planet of the Apes... Saving Private Ryan... High Noon... Film-Fest 4: Sundance 2000 & Hawaii... Me Without You... Kodo... Reflections on the Fade of Daytime's Guiding Light... HBO's Grey Gardens Explores an Inexplicable Enigma... What Happens in Vegas Diverting... Some Like It Hot... EARTH DAY: Digesting our planet... Warner offers HD-to-Blu-ray upgrades for $4.95... A Look Back: 1999... Before Night Falls... WELCOME TO THE NEW dOc!... |
A&E Home Video presents "And when Lord Carnarvon, unable to stand the suspense, inquired anxiously, 'Can you see anything?' [I responded,] 'Yes, wonderful things!'"
DVD ReviewOne of my great memories of the 1970s was a field trip to the Field Museum to see the treasures of King Tutankhamen (or Tutankhamun, as this keepcase cover spells it). Now those treasures are on tour in the US once again after nearly 30 years, making this disc devoted to the Boy King and the discovery of his tomb timely indeed.The discovery of Tut's tomb in 1922 in the Valley of the Kings, the only basically undisturbed burial chamber of a pharoah ever to be found, made headlines around the world. Ever since, the glorious treasures from that tomb have fascinated people. This documentary, from the Mummies series, covers the history of the find in depth, as well as archaeologist Howard Carter's career prior to his greatest discovery. Particularly interesting is his rather brute force approach to finding Tut's tomb: excavate everything likely in the Valley of the Kings right down to the bedrock. Frank Langella contributes the narration, while there are a number of interviewees from various museums who fill in archaeological details. Historians contribute what little is known for sure about Tut's brief reign, and his important role in reuniting Egypt after the heresies of Akhenaten. Still photos and a few bits of silent footage from Carter's excavations provide immediacy to the story. We also get quite a few shots, in close detail of the treasures from the tomb, allowing a vivid examination not possible even in person. One interesting point is the straightforward debunking of the entire 'curse' story, which basically gets appropriately short shrift. The one point that may cause some viewers discomfort are rare shots of the unwrapped mummy itself, which had been dismembered by Carter in order to remove it from its coffin. The film winds up with excavations of a nearby site in 1995 that had been buried by Carter's rubble from the excavations for Tut, which promised equally interesting finds. It would have been nice to include a short update on this point to let the viewer know what, if anything, has been found in the last decade. Rating for Style: B Rating for Substance: B+ Image Transfer
Image Transfer Review: The film footage all looks fine, with some mild edge enhancement and aliasing that is particularly an issue on still photographs. On the whole, however, the film has excellent color and good detail that belies its television origins. Image Transfer Grade: B+ Audio Transfer
Audio Transfer Review: The 2.0 audio is almost entirely localized in the center channel with Pro Logic engaged; only occasional surround information is included. While it has a narrow soundstage, the audio track is very clean and the narration is always easily understandable. Audio Transfer Grade: B Disc ExtrasStatic menuScene Access with 6 cues and remote access 2 Documentaries Packaging: Amaray Picture Disc 1 Disc 1-Sided disc(s) Layers: dual Extras Review: The extras are two more hour-long programs related to Tut. A Biography episode devoted to Howard Carter provides even more background information and discusses his post-Tut life in some detail, including his resentment at being disregarded for knighthood. More problematic is the Investigating History episode devoted to the supposed Curse. It has some merits, such as taking an epidemiological approach to determining whether the curse is real. The show is rather schizophrenic in presentation, with interviewee after interviewee denying there is any such curse (for example, no such curse was inscribed on the tomb, nor anywhere in the tomb) and the narrator breathlessly plunging ahead in the faint hope that there really is one. He pays no attention, for instance, to the fact that Lord Carnarvon, who died shortly after the tomb was opened, was in Egypt in the first place because of his extremely poor health. On the positive side, it includes substantially more footage of the Carter excavations, making it a valuable document if you disregard the narrator's rantings. Extras Grade: B+ Final CommentsA solid if too short look at the tomb of the Boy King, with a nice sharp transfer. Two bonus documentaries provide interesting looks at two diverse facets and help provide substantial value. |
|
| Become a Reviewer | Search | Review Vault | Reviewers Readers | Webmasters | Privacy | Contact |
||||
|
|